Menu
Burke Index
RESEARCH
10.09.2025, 10:34
Alternative Solutions to Preserve the Sovereignty of Atoll Island States

...the first problem is a lack of sufficient consensus on the criteria for statehood. Also the establishment of legally binding criteria, as opposed to politically judged factors, is not widely supported in practice. Many authors maintain that states consider various factors, but the final determination ranges from a purely political one to one at least intimately bound to political considerations, not as a neutral assessment of fixed criteria. 

The 1933 Montevideo Convention in its Art. 1 enumerates the criteria for statehood, which are a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and the capacity to enter into relations with other States. However, during its existence a State might increase or decrease in territory, its population oscillate and the capacity to enter into relations with other States vary. As Worster points out, the criteria for statehood is contentious and practice has not been consistent in international law. Although it is taken for granted that the Montevideo requirements should be met, there is ample evidence demonstrating that opportunism also plays an important role on the establishment and recognition of States.